Calvin Coolidge: An Economic General Who Cut Taxes & Produced Surpluses

Mr. Merry, editor of the National Interest, is the author of “Where They Stand: The American Presidents in the Eyes of Voters and Historians.

n 1920, Coolidge emerged as the running mate to Republican presidential candidate Warren Harding, an intellectually lethargic man who nonetheless understood the need to remake the GOP into a more conservative party and move the country in a new direction. President Woodrow Wilson’s postwar economy was in free fall, and the country needed a new economic philosophy to get beyond the Wilson mess.

Harding’s watchword was “normalcy”—meaning, as Ms. Shlaes describes it, “low taxes, tariffs, less central government, and stability.” He won in a landslide, a clear repudiation of Wilson’s progressive policies, and quickly moved, at the counsel of Treasury Secretary Andrew Mellon, to cut taxes and restore the economy. The aim, says Ms. Shlaes: “to retire debt, not to expand it.”

The new direction was well-established by August 1923, when Harding died unexpectedly at age 57, most likely from congestive heart failure. But Mellon believed the new president could generate continuing economic growth through greater application of a “scientific taxation” concept—”supply side” economics, in today’s parlance—designed to generate economic activity, and federal revenue, by reducing top marginal tax rates. In Coolidge’s time, as today, the concept stirred widespread skepticism.

Coolidge sent to Congress a “scientific taxation” bill that he hoped to get passed before he faced the voters in 1924—proposing to lower the top tax rate to 30% or even 25% from 50% (it had been 77% when Harding took office). The party establishment in Congress watered it down, leaving the top tax rate at 43.5% and directing most of the tax relief to middle-income Americans. Though disappointed, Coolidge signed the bill with a resolve to revisit the matter after his election, in which he defeated Democratic candidate John W. Davis by a decisive margin.

He eventually got the top rate down to 25%. The GDP soared, increasing by 25% during the Harding-Coolidge years. The result, coupled with fiscal austerity, was a nation flush with tax receipts—surpluses of $100 million in 1925, $375 million in 1926 and nearly $600 million the next year.

The Coolidge years represent the country’s most distilled experiment in supply-side economics—and the doctrine’s most conspicuous success. That success is the central Coolidge legacy, brought home with telling authority in Ms. Shlaes’s work. This book’s time is propitious. As the nation faces a looming economic crisis wrought in large measure by mounting public debt, the Coolidge experiment offers insights into what an alternative course might look like. Ms. Shlaes has given us a detailed examination of that alternative course

A version of this article appeared February 9, 2013, on page C5 in the U.S. edition of The Wall Street Journal, with the headline: Calvin Coolidge for President.

This entry was posted in Conservatism, Economics, Politics, Republicans and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Calvin Coolidge: An Economic General Who Cut Taxes & Produced Surpluses

  1. Brigitte says:

    I believe what you published was very logical.
    But, what about this? suppose you composed a catchier post title?
    I ain’t saying your information is not solid, however what if you added something to possibly get people’s attention?
    I mean Calvin Coolidge: An Economic General Who Cut Taxes &
    Produced Surpluses | Miscellaneous Musings of a Meandering Mind is kinda plain.
    You should peek at Yahoo’s home page and note how they create news titles to grab viewers to click. You might add a video or a picture or two to get readers excited about everything’ve written.
    Just my opinion, it could make your website a little livelier.

    • tmkeel says:

      Brigitte, It sounds as if you are an editor. Either that or you are a marketing major. If you will notice, the subtitle of my WordPress blog is “a place to put things.” And, that is simply what this is. I have an interest in so many different topics that when I find something that interests me, unlike previously when I would clip articles and place them in a folder, I now store them electronically and access them at any time. If others find them and pique their interests, that is fine with me, however, that is not my primary focus. Although, I am very grateful for the suggestions and were I a “real” blogger, I would definitely follow that. What I am doing at this point in my life, as a senior citizen who is retired, is to take all my photographs, papers, movies, etc. and digitizing them so that my children will not have mountains of things to go through upon my departure, everything will be in digital formats, stored both on-site and in the cloud. Please contact me at any time with any suggestions that you may have. I enjoy hearing from others.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s